diff --git a/books_disliked.html b/books_disliked.html index f7aa099..cba902f 100644 --- a/books_disliked.html +++ b/books_disliked.html @@ -21,6 +21,9 @@ the name of Lord Christ Jesus. Amen.
  • Stephen Black. "I ate Tiong Bahru".
  • +
  • Editor: Kirpal Singh. "Interlogue: Studies in Singapore Literature. Volume 2: Poetry". + +
  • Jee Leong Koh. "Equal to the Earth".
  • @@ -98,6 +101,38 @@ Does Mr. Black come across as astute, through the pages of this book? I leave it


    + +
    +

    Editor: Kirpal Singh. "Interlogue: Studies in Singapore Literature. Volume 2: Poetry". +

    +

    +I felt turned off by the Introduction. (And stopped reading shortly after that). +

    +

    +I take issue with how the (un-identified) writer of the Introduction - whom I guess to be Mr. Kirpal Singh - focused on the "what should" instead of "what is". +A sentence like "we must set our standards as any genuinely independent nation must and it is by these standards that we should judge ourselves" seems to be more + appropriate for a book titled "Mr. Kirpal Singh's Opinions" instead of a book titled "Studies in Singapore Literature: Volume 2: Poetry". +

    +

    +A reader with an interest in delightful poetry may be better served by reading Jane Hirshfield's book, "Nine gates: Entering the mind of poetry". Ms. Hirshfield talks engagingly about the "what is" instead of "what should", as I fondly recall. +

    +

    +And a reader with a curiosity towards poetry from Singapore may be better served by + reading the selection at: + +https://www.lyrikline.org/en/authors?nav=1&country%5B%5D=SG + +

    +

    +Please let me conclude by saying this book seems to be crying out for a healthy dose of humour. May I quote from Eric Linklater's lovely 1929 work, "Poet's pub"? +The fictional character of Sir Philip Betts, a professor, remarks (on Page 33 of my copy, published by The Penguin Group): "I'm sick of scholarship and the graveyard +way we go to work explaining what Shakespeare meant in places where all he meant, probably, was a billiard-room joke." +

    +

    - 24th May 2021. +

    +
    +
    +

    Jee Leong Koh. "Equal to the Earth".